Guy promised no rust, only rust repair done very well with solid metal everywhere. Wheelwells all repaired with real metal, no bondo or fiberglass. Then the all the bits that typically rust were coated with the best stuff ever, the plastic thats used to coat pickup beds. A-and its got a new paint job, only a teaspoon of bondo on the whole car. Excellent condition runs strong, 30mpg! Asking $7950.
Looks sharp eh?
Looks good from the outside.
I can’t find the craigslist ad any more, but I see some commentary about it here.
The odd thing about the post on IH8Mud.com? I found it only after calling the guy and arranging to drive up and see it. So much for the internets, someone claims its sold, but its not? Its 2 hour drive to his place. Brought my son so see it too. He sounded like a bit of a wheeler dealer on the phone, car wasn’t registered in washington, he’d done this before, etc, etc. Hmm. Well see.
4 Speed Vs 5 Speed
This is a 4 speed, so has longer gears than the 5 speed. From forums I see people paying $3,000-$6,000 to convert their 4 speeds to the 5 speed. 5 speed is better for matching the weak engine power to the speed and makes for quieter and more economical motoring. At least thats what the internets say. 🙂
I also find sane posts that state the 5 speed makes little to no difference, that fuel economy for a brick like this is dominated by air resistance, that there’s simply no way to get good mileage above 55mph, and lots of little things hurt the fuel economy. Driving fast hurts mileage, so do wide tires and lifting your truck. Also a sweet rack will kill your mileage.
From my sample of the ravening internets: the 30mpg people are infected with positive enthusiasm and are merely projecting their hopes and dreams to the world, and that they might also be using Imperial Gallons in their MPG figure (imperial gallon is 120% of a U.S. gallon). Figures I trust off the forums indicated that 25-28 is possible with skinny tires IF you’re light on the pedal.
Anyway, seller on the phone says that 4 speeds get 30mpg, 5 speeds get 35mpg. I ask if he’s experienced that himself with this truck: Um.. no.. this truck isn’t registered.., um I don’t know what the actual mileage is. So he is just reporting the best internet figures as fact? Hmm…
Hey, at least he isn’t lying. If he was deposed he could claim ignorance instead of being sleazy.
Was the Scouting Mission a Waste of Time?
This was a scout mission so I didn’t bring money and did not expecting to offer anything since he sounded so evasive. What I did bring was a headlamp, some eye protection, camera and some gloves. Intend to check it thoroughly for rust, then send photos to independant shop if the vehicle is a candidate.
Drive up, actually 2.5 hours, traffic and pouring rain the entire way. Full 20 gallons of premium gas.
On the outside the truck looks fine. Actually better than fine. I borrow a sheet of plywood and climb under with my new headlamp, camera and eye protection. Guy looks sort of surprised.
What I find is not what I expected:
- To my uneducated Elitist Porsche Owning Eye there’s just Tons-O-Rust. Rear frame is Gone, as in not there any more. There are cross supports missing. Leaf springs are sheets of rust, the shackles are invisible under a thick layered flaking ball of red disease. Metal is blooming into elaborate rust formations. Holes and rust through the thick metal of the frame, edges are fractal like a coral reef.
- The inside of the frame was rusted away, then taped over with thin tape and all painted a uniform black. It might have been treated with something, but big holes in a box tube does not bode well for its strength.
- Those wheel wells that had been so excellently repaired with Solid Metal? Chunks of fiberglass were breaking loose, tons of sopping rust came out the other side. Fiberglass over rust is exactly the worst thing you can do. Or maybe not, maybe its parking it in the ocean.
- This is the degreee of failure that I’ve been warned about since middle school but never actually seen. I could pretty easily have pulled baseball size chunks of sodden rusty fiberglass out of the wheelwell. Entire thing wanted to come loose and I don’t want to see whats back there.
- Behind wheelwell in the back, under the carpet? There is thick surface rust. Felt like I could have gone deep with a screwdriver, met up with the grungy delights in the wheel well. The metal in the cabin flexed with only the lightest finger taps.
- All four bottom edges of the doors were so rusted they flexed with a light squeeze. I could have broken them off with my fingers.
- Forget the screwdriver, or a hammer. I could have put 10’s of holes into this vehicle with my fingers. Had to be careful not to damage it.
On the bright side:
- The most classic of all rust locations, the rear lift gate, is not rusted at all (seller assures me that is rare!) Oh, huh. Because its new.
- There is a triangular sheet metal tunnel between the front and back of the body, before the wheel wells. Internet had warned this was the place to look for rust on otherwise clean vehicles. Its pretty much right below the back of the rear passanger seat. On this car I could site down it while under the car and it looked pretty darn good. A little wet, but not exploding with rust. I dunno? It looks like a place that is perfect for accumulating rust, and I didn’t see it.
So much for bright spots: at this point the car is only worth its drive train, and I’m not looking for a standalone drive train. Not something I want at all, even for free.
The Big Question
Why would someone bother to put a nice paintjob on this car, and not repair the real problems? Is this the Classic Lipstick on Pig? I can only guess that the seller is looking to pass this disaster off to an Idiot. Paint the doors nicely, but leave them full of rust along the lower edges? Sure does smell dishonest to me. Never in my life have I encountered such a dishonest presentation. I hope I’m wrong here but putting the black painted bandages over the badly rusted frame doesn’t seem like a good patch, seems like a way to hide the frame damage from a casual observer that just pokes his head under the car. Those patches would have been tough to find without a headlamp. Caveat Emptor!
Dang. What a waste of time. Oh well, anyway the first BJ60 that I’ve laid eyes upon. Hopefully the cars I look at will only get better from here?
Oh Yeah, That Silver Lining: The BJ60 is Freakin’ Awesome!!
He offers to let me drive it. I start it up and engine sounds VERY good. Just lugs along at a very low idle. Sounds very tight and clean. To my ears it sounds better than a classic air cooled opposed 6. No odd smoke or anything on cold startup. New clutch. We drive it down his driveway and onto paved road. Steering is loose, has a bit of the crab walk. Sorta kinda dangerous how difficult it is to keep on the road, bouncing around at odd angles. But wow it seems powerful. Way more powerful than you’d think from 70hp.
On the way back on the gravel we switch it into Low, engage the front hubs. Wow that is cool. Drive at 2000rpm and go about 5mph. This would be so choice in Teapot Canyon.
Best part of the whole trip: guy gets out to switch back the front hubs, he leans back to my son: This is gunna be your job! Slams the door. Son leans forward and exclaims: ” Dad. We gotta get this truck!” Low and urgent tone in his voice, not heard that tone from him before.
So this thing – tarted up on the outside but deadly rust monster on the inside. BEWARE!
On the bright side, he did let me drive it and he did a great job of selling my son and I on the vehicle type. I hope this bj60 ends up in a good home, its a cool car that looks to need $7000-$10,000 in rust repair. Much cheaper to port this drivetrain onto a clean FJ60. But that leaves a rusty hulk with nice paint with no purpose in life. Again: why would anyone pay anything to paint it and not fix the rust? Are dumb buyers so common?